What Secret Shopping Reveals About Employee Experience
Customer experience reflects employee experience. After 25 years, this pattern never changes.
After 25 years of secret shopping, I can predict the customer experience before I even interact with staff. How? By watching how employees behave when they think nobody's paying attention.
Customer experience and employee experience are inseparable. You cannot deliver a great customer experience if your employees are frustrated, confused, or burnt out.
When I walk into a business, I'm watching body language, energy, and how staff interact with each other before I even say hello.
Employees who avoid eye contact. This isn't shyness. It's exhaustion or disengagement. Staff who feel supported and valued greet customers naturally.
Staff complaining in earshot of customers. When employees openly vent about policies, schedules, or management, it tells me the feedback loop is broken. They've given up on internal channels.
Confusion about procedures. When staff hesitate, ask each other questions mid-transaction, or seem unsure of basic processes, it's a training issue - but it's also a morale issue. Nobody likes feeling incompetent at their job.
High energy from some, low energy from others. Inconsistent engagement across a team usually means favoritism, unclear expectations, or burnout that's not being addressed.
The businesses that score highest in my evaluations have employees who:
- Move with purpose - They're busy but not frantic, efficient but not robotic
- Help each other without being asked - There's natural collaboration, not competition
- Speak positively about the business - Not fake enthusiasm, but genuine pride
- Handle problems calmly - They have the authority and training to fix issues
- Greet customers warmly - It feels authentic because they're not miserable
These behaviors don't happen by accident. They're the result of good systems, clear communication, proper training, and leadership that actually supports the team.
I've seen the same morale killers across thousands of evaluations:
Unclear expectations. Employees don't know what success looks like, so they're always second-guessing themselves. This creates anxiety, not engagement.
No decision-making authority. Staff have to ask permission for everything, even obvious things. This is exhausting and demoralizing.
Inconsistent enforcement. Rules apply to some people but not others. Or policies exist but aren't followed. This breeds resentment.
Poor communication from leadership. Changes happen without explanation. Questions go unanswered. Feedback disappears into a void.
No recognition. Good work goes unnoticed. Mistakes get immediate attention. Employees learn that effort doesn't matter.
Here's what business owners often miss: you can't hide poor employee experience from customers.
When staff are frustrated, customers feel it. When processes are unclear, customers experience the confusion. When morale is low, service suffers.
I've evaluated businesses where the product was excellent but the customer experience was terrible - not because the staff were bad, but because they were operating in a bad system.
And I've evaluated businesses where the product was average but the customer experience was exceptional - because the employees were happy, trained, and empowered.
Based on 25 years of observations, here's what actually works:
1. Clarify expectations. Every role should have clear responsibilities, standards, and success metrics. Ambiguity creates stress.
2. Train properly. Don't just show people what to do - explain why it matters and give them time to practice. Confidence comes from competence.
3. Give authority to solve problems. If you want staff to take ownership, they need the power to make decisions within clear boundaries.
4. Communicate consistently. Regular updates, clear channels for questions, and actual responses to feedback. Communication can't be one-way.
5. Recognize good work. Not just with words - with raises, opportunities, and visible appreciation. People notice who gets rewarded.
6. Fix broken processes. When staff complain about a procedure that doesn't make sense, listen. They're on the front lines and often know better than management.
I've evaluated mom-and-pop shops and multi-million dollar operations. The size doesn't matter.
Businesses that treat employee experience as a priority deliver better customer experiences. Businesses that ignore employee experience struggle with retention, consistency, and quality.
It's not complicated. You can't build a great customer experience on top of a broken employee experience.
Fix the foundation first.
Want operational insights for your business?
Book a Flow Check to get an expert evaluation of your systems.
Learn about Flow Check →